Chief Deputy on “victimization”

Kirk Torgensen, chief deputy in the Utah Attorney General’s Office, spoke Tuesday at the National Organization For Victim Assistance conference, being held in Salt Lake City.

His topic? “Polygamy Victimization.”

Former plural wife Carolyn Jessop also spoke. More on her in the next post. But here is a recap of what Torgensen had to say.

He credited Carolyn for opening his eyes — even changing his life — to what was going in in the twin towns of Hildale, Utah, and Colorado City, Ariz.

Think about a world in which young girls are raised with very little freedom and, when they reach 13 or 14 or 15, are told by a prophet to marry a much older man because “it’s just the way it is,” Torgensen said.

In the twin towns, young people don’t have the freedom, the constitutional right, to live the way they want to, he said.

He read an excerpt from Elissa Wall’s book “Stolen Innocence”— a “marvelous book” — in which she describes crying in the bathroom after being married in 2001 to Allen G. Steed.

As he read out loud, heads shook in disbelief throughout the audience, which I would estimate included several thousand victim advocates from throughout the country.

“I don’t know if any of us can imagine what that’s like — to be in a country where we have freedom but these folks don’t,” he said, as photos taken on Wall’s wedding day were displayed on screens on either side of the stage.

“This should not happen to any 14-year-old,” Torgensen said.

He said the state’s interest in stopping the child bride marriages had nothing to do with religion. No matter what religion they are, someone who engages in such behavior “is a child rapist,” he said.

He cited the biblical phrase “by their fruits you will know them” and then said: “The religion I belong to doesn’t believe in doing this to young kids.”

Torgensen said polygamist Tom Green did the state a favor when he publicized his beliefs and lifestyle on national television, which led to his prosecution and conviction in 2001 on charges of bigamy and failure to pay child support.

Green “peeled off the layers nobody had seen,” Torgensen said.

Torgensen said every time he visits the twin towns he is followed. “It’s like some bizarre place that’s been picked up and moved to the border here,” he said of the polygamous community.

With a photograph of Rodney Holm, two wives and his children as a backdrop, Torgensen said: “See, the state of Utah allowed him to be a police officer.”

He said that after learning about Holm, he said to himself: “What in the world, how could this guy be a police officer?”

But prosecuting Holm proved difficult because the witness, the younger sister of one of his wives, kept reneging on her willingness to testify about her own marriage to Holm.

“Has this problem gone away for us? No,” Torgensen said.

Despite decertifying numerous officers in the community, “we still have this issue going on today” and there is a lack of the kind of law enforcement that is needed in the towns, he said.

Torgensen then projected a photo series that showed FLDS church leader Warren Jeffs standing with and kissing a 12-year-old girl he allegedly married in Texas.

Said Torgensen: “I am so thankful this photo was shown to the world.”

He said Texas is actively prosecuting the case and “my prediction is Mr. Jeffs is going to find justice in Texas.”

Torgensen projected excerpts from Jeffs’ written journal as he described how the state had warned the FLDS around 2002 to stop endorsing underage marriage.

“We told them, ‘You’ve got to leave these kids alone.’ They said, ‘yeah, we understand.’”

He then displayed excerpts from Jeffs’ written journal — dated Jan. 10, 2003, Jan. 16, 2003 and Aug. 19, 2004.

In one, Jeffs described being asked by other polygamous groups to knock off underage marriages. In other he spoke of the state pressure and said: “It is so easy to get around it.”

Torgensen said the amount of money the FLDS were paying lawyers to “get around it” was “astounding.”

As for the people themselves, he said he wasn’t sure they were “capable of making decisions on their own” after so many years of “indoctrination.”

“There is absolutely nothing we’ve ever told them that has soaked in,” he said. “I don’t know what it takes for these people. . . their own lawyers can say, ‘Are you stupid?’”

That comment was made with this text, taken from a 2002 speech given by FLDS member Sam Barlow, displayed on the screen:

One of the attorneys said to me, “If you don’t make some concession on whether or not you will continue to marry young ladies to old men, then you’ll be caught in the same net and trap and under the same pressure that John Taylor was in in his time.”

I said, “I’m aware of that but we are born to this conflict and we will have to endure equal pressure to what the saints were under then if we are going to annul the convenant with death and hell that was entered into.”

Torgensen said that people want to know why the state doesn’t “prosecute a whole slew of these people.”

He blamed an “incredible secrecy” and the lack of young women coming forward with complaints. Without that, “I haven’t got a case,” he said.

“You can go after organized crime easier than you can these people,” he added.

But in Texas, law officers were able to get a “treasure trove” of information that “I am so grateful for.”

The FLDS have never listened to state officials, he said. “They’ve played us.”

Torgensen then described meeting with “another guy” from the FLDS community, adding that “I don’t know what to call him — Willie Jessop.”

Torgensen said Jessop told him that underage marriages had stopped which Torgensen called “yet another attempt to blow smoke at me.”

“This was before all the stuff in Texas went down,” he added.

(Asked later about that comment, Jessop said he had never met Torgensen until some months after the April 2008 raid on the sect’s Yearning For Zion Ranch in Eldorado, Texas. Jessop said he flew to Utah from Texas in June or July of that year, which is about when the sect issued a public statement saying underage marriages would no longer be allowed. “I never talked to anybody on any such thing before Texas,” Jessop said.)

Torgensen said the FLDS are “still trying to tell us what they think we want to hear and I don’t believe it for a second.”

In an aside, he told the audience  that he had no tolerance for religious beliefs that harmed children. “Why should a young person die because their parent has some goofed up religious view?” he asked.

Clarification: This comment from Kirk Torgensen (Why should a child die?) was not necessarily directed at the FLDS but at parents whose beliefs potentially put their children’s lives in jeopardy, such as Jehovah’s Witnesses and Christian Science.

Torgensen said that law enforcement efforts were “starting to come to fruition” and he was “very grateful” for that.

He described how “simple mathematics” was driving young boys out of the community, with help of harassment from the local FLDS cops.

Guess who the justice of the peace enforcing those citations used to be? he asked his audience. A polygamist whose ultimate oath was to the prophet, Torgensen said.

He described how Elissa Wall’s older brother was kicked out of his family’s home, driven to the city limits and dropped off. “Unbelievable,” he said.

(The incident happened in the Salt Lake Valley, not the twin towns, and the brother was 21-years-old. He asked to be driven to a highway, where he could hitch a ride to Denver, according to Wall’s book.)

“They find reasons to get rid of these young men,” he said, and many then turn to substance abuse.

“It makes me incredibly sad to believe this is going on,” Torgensen said.

As for the men standing trial in Texas, Torgensen said he hopes they are convicted and that “they stay in a prison cell for a long time.” The comment drew thunderous applause from the audience.

“Something is wrong with a group of men who can’t wait until someone is 18″ to marry, he said, adding that the proper term for such abusers is “pedophiles.”

“We don’t owe them an apology for anything,” he said. “For that, I hope they get everything they’ve got coming to them.”

7 Comments

  1. MA_Matriarch says:

    “Why should a young person die because their parent has some goofed up religious view?” he asked.

    Die??? Laying it on pretty thick and heavy.

    “There is absolutely nothing we’ve ever told them that has soaked in,” he said. “I don’t know what it takes for these people. . . their own lawyers can say, ‘Are you stupid?’”

    No, they have beliefs which obviously those OUTSIDE the culture are willing to comprehend.

    Very insulting, sad commentary.

  2. First Amendment says:

    Kirk tells Dan Fischer for years that he can’t act without evidence, so Fischer sends his lost boys and lost girls to an LDS priest/therapist and has them hypnotized. And they write books and Kirk reads them and dutifully spreads the word to thunderous applause. But when is Kirk going to do his job and ask how much in these books (and court testimony) is real, and how much is the fictional product of hypnosis by a priest who is convinced that the FLDS are evil, and paid for by a dentist who has sworn revenge on the leader of the church?

    When is Kirk going to identify the dead person he talking about when he says, “Why should a young person die because their parent has some goofed up religious view?” Is he talking about all those gay kids who commit suicide because the LDS church won’t except homosexuality?

    And when is Kirk going to recognize that this “treasure trove” in Texas is exactly the sort of trove that you would find if you performed an illegal general search on any monogamist community. What would Kirk find if he did a snap search on all of Dan Fischer’s allies? A haul of guns and drugs and pornography, most likely. And if Kirk were an anti-monogamist living in a polygamist community, he could work himself up into a demagogic lather about the evils of monogamy…all to thunderous applause. There are a hundred thousand books featuring the evils of monogamy, after all. It’s just that they don’t have the word “monogamy” on the cover, but the rapes and incest and spousal abuse in the greater society is so universal that he doesn’t see it.

  3. Brooke says:

    Clarification: This comment from Kirk Torgensen (Why should a child die?) was not necessarily directed at the FLDS but at parents whose beliefs potentially put their children’s lives in jeopardy, such as Jehovah’s Witnesses and Christian Science.

  4. Freethinker says:

    Brooke, why should you feel to defend Mr Torgensen’s comment? It sounded just like he said it and is typical of the the incendiary comments suffered endlessly by the FLDS. His being followed whenever he goes to H/CC smacks of paranoia.

  5. Arturo says:

    Seeing as how everyone is throwing around young girls being married to older men lets realize that, yes, Elissa Wall was too young to be married but she was not married to an old man. So why the constant harping on younger women marring older men. Also she could not have been as innocent and nieve as you would all like to beleive if she was able to start another relationship in secret and get pregnant with another mans child with out her husband knowing anything about it. Obviously she had enough freedom to be able to do that and to finally leave of her own will and choice.

  6. WATCHING says:

    Different religions have allowed their children to die – and in fact as I recall in this particular sect, an underage mother was prevented from going to a hospital after a 3 day problem labor the flds dr couldnt help with as I recall.

    Another polygamist sect in no Utah had a young mother die in a similar case. I think the husband went to jail for that too.

    The problems of fumarase deficiency, which causes FLDS children to die young, has been swept under the rug as well. Its a known fact that that genetic disease has occured more often to the FLDS than anywhere on earth, yet there is nothing done to prevent it. So yes he wasnt far off the mark.

  7. Rebeckah says:

    “Seeing as how everyone is throwing around young girls being married to older men lets realize that, yes, Elissa Wall was too young to be married but she was not married to an old man. So why the constant harping on younger women marring older men.”

    Because Elissa was one case of underage marriage but there are many others. Warren himself had several underage brides, one of whom was barely 12 when he married her. And yes, he’s an old man — old enough to be the grandfather of the underage girls he pretended to marry.

    “Also she could not have been as innocent and nieve as you would all like to beleive if she was able to start another relationship in secret and get pregnant with another mans child with out her husband knowing anything about it.”

    Why would her actions years later have any impact on her innocence or naivete at the age of 14? And why do you feel the need to trash her? Has she actually harmed you in some way?

    “Obviously she had enough freedom to be able to do that and to finally leave of her own will and choice.”

    She suffered through her teenage years when she should have been gaining an education and maturing. The fact that she was eventually able to find the strength to leave in no way mitigates the harm done to her when she was vulnerable — helpless even.

    A 14 year old girl should NEVER be placed in the position she was.